The making of a woman's town : household and gender in Dundee 1890 to 1940
From the introduction: Women in Dundee's history are often portrayed as different from women who lived elsewhere. Their ability to survive difficulty has been praised by some historians (see, for example, Gordon, 1991), while other historians have gone so far as to claim that they displayed masculine characteristics (see, for example, Walker, 1979). Oral evidence suggests that Dundee women seem to have had a much more developed level of gender and class consciousness than other women achieved. Some of these women expressed and used this understanding in their own working lives. For example, Bella Keyzer was a woman who fought, in the 1960s, to return to her wartime trade as a welder. In the late 1980s, Bella appeared in a number of television oral histories, in which she was often presented as a feminist, particularly since her critique of gender definitions of skill and wage rates fitted radical feminism so closely. Like others in Dundee, however she was keen to emphasise that her ideology was recognised as arising out of practical experiences, rather than from theoretical musings.
Smith, Graham R.
Housing Scotland Dundee ; Women Scotland Conduct of life ; Women Scotland Social conditions
The making of a woman's town : household and gender in Dundee 1890 to 1940. From the introduction: Women in Dundee's history are often portrayed as different from women who lived elsewhere. Their ability to survive difficulty has been praised by some historians (see, for example, Gordon, 1991), while other historians have gone so far as to claim that they displayed masculine characteristics (see, for example, Walker, 1979). Oral evidence suggests that Dundee women seem to have had a much more developed level of gender and class consciousness than other women achieved. Some of these women expressed and used this understanding in their own working lives. For example, Bella Keyzer was a woman who fought, in the 1960s, to return to her wartime trade as a welder. In the late 1980s, Bella appeared in a number of television oral histories, in which she was often presented as a feminist, particularly since her critique of gender definitions of skill and wage rates fitted radical feminism so closely. Like others in Dundee, however she was keen to emphasise that her ideology was recognised as arising out of practical experiences, rather than from theoretical musings.
make woman town household gender dundee introduction women dundee history often portray different woman_live elsewhere ability survive difficulty praise historian see example historians far claim displayed masculine characteristic see example oral_evidence suggest dundee woman seem much develop level gender_class consciousness woman achieve woman express used work life example woman fight return wartime trade appear number television oral_history often present feminist particularly since critique gender definition skill wage rate fit radical feminism closely like others dundee however keen emphasise ideology recognise arise practical experience rather theoretical