Revising the supernatural : the inquiry on miracles in early modern canonisation trials
Making use of both published treatises and archival documents, this dissertation explains the reasons for the birth of a new concept of miracle in early modern canonisation trials held in Papal Rome. From the twelfth century, Catholic tradition had long defined a miracle as an event exceeding the whole of the order of nature, which meant both the visible and corporeal as well as the invisible and spiritual order. However, during the seventeenth century, Aristotelian physics was replaced by a new way of investigating nature, focused on mathematics as a method of inquiry, on mechanical explanations and on a new idea of matter based on corpuscular philosophy and atomism. This led to a new idea of nature. In the canonisation process, alleged miracles were assessed by a committee, who engaged medical experts with the role of evaluating any possibility that the events had natural causes. Between the end of seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, Roman physicians largely employed mechanical physics to investigate nature. This caused a short circuit: the new idea of nature implicit in the medical expertsâ investigations did not coincide with the idea of nature from which the medieval definition of miracle had
Laverda, Alessandro
Revising the supernatural : the inquiry on miracles in early modern canonisation trials. Making use of both published treatises and archival documents, this dissertation explains the reasons for the birth of a new concept of miracle in early modern canonisation trials held in Papal Rome. From the twelfth century, Catholic tradition had long defined a miracle as an event exceeding the whole of the order of nature, which meant both the visible and corporeal as well as the invisible and spiritual order. However, during the seventeenth century, Aristotelian physics was replaced by a new way of investigating nature, focused on mathematics as a method of inquiry, on mechanical explanations and on a new idea of matter based on corpuscular philosophy and atomism. This led to a new idea of nature. In the canonisation process, alleged miracles were assessed by a committee, who engaged medical experts with the role of evaluating any possibility that the events had natural causes. Between the end of seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries, Roman physicians largely employed mechanical physics to investigate nature. This caused a short circuit: the new idea of nature implicit in the medical expertsâ investigations did not coincide with the idea of nature from which the medieval definition of miracle had
supernatural inquiry miracle early_modern trial making use publish treatise archival_document explain reason birth new concept miracle early_modern trial hold papal rome catholic tradition long define miracle event exceed whole order nature meant visible corporeal well invisible spiritual order however aristotelian physic replace new_way investigating nature focus mathematics method inquiry mechanical explanation new_idea matter base philosophy atomism lead new_idea nature process allege miracle assess committee engage medical expert role evaluate possibility event natural cause roman largely employed mechanical physic investigate_nature cause short circuit new_idea nature implicit medical expert investigation coincide idea nature medieval definition miracle