Theory construction in second language acquisition
Whereas ten years ago most SLA researchers assumed a rationalist, ~scientific~ approach to theory construction, recently, growing numbers have adopted relativist positions that strongly criticise the methods, and authority of the rationalist/empiricist paradigm. Apart from the problem of research methodology, other problems make progress in the construction of a theory of SLA difficult: the proliferation of theories, contradictions among them, and, most important of all, confusion about the domain and objectives of a theory of SLA. This thesis addresses the problems outlined above by returning to first principles and asking what it is that we can know about the world, whether there is any such thing as reliable knowledge, what is special about scientific methodology, and what the best way of tackling the complex task of explaining SLA might be. While previous surveys of SLA research exist, no previous attempt has been made to examine SLA research in terms of its epistemological underpinnings and its relation to scientific method, or to evaluate different research programmes and putative theories in terms of how they form part of, and contribute towards, a rational, scientific explanation of the phenomena of
Jordan, Geoffrey
Theory construction in second language acquisition. Whereas ten years ago most SLA researchers assumed a rationalist, ~scientific~ approach to theory construction, recently, growing numbers have adopted relativist positions that strongly criticise the methods, and authority of the rationalist/empiricist paradigm. Apart from the problem of research methodology, other problems make progress in the construction of a theory of SLA difficult: the proliferation of theories, contradictions among them, and, most important of all, confusion about the domain and objectives of a theory of SLA. This thesis addresses the problems outlined above by returning to first principles and asking what it is that we can know about the world, whether there is any such thing as reliable knowledge, what is special about scientific methodology, and what the best way of tackling the complex task of explaining SLA might be. While previous surveys of SLA research exist, no previous attempt has been made to examine SLA research in terms of its epistemological underpinnings and its relation to scientific method, or to evaluate different research programmes and putative theories in terms of how they form part of, and contribute towards, a rational, scientific explanation of the phenomena of
theory construction second_language_acquisition whereas sla researcher assume rationalist scientific_theory construction recently grow_number adopt position strongly criticise method authority rationalist empiricist paradigm apart problem problem make_progress construction theory sla difficult proliferation theory contradiction among_important confusion domain objective theory sla address_problem outline return first principle ask know world whether thing reliable knowledge special scientific best_way tackle complex task explain sla might previous survey sla exist previous_attempt make examine sla term epistemological underpinnings relation scientific_method evaluate_different programme putative theory term form_part contribute_towards rational scientific_explanation phenomenon