To each according to deeds : divine judgement according to deeds in second temple Judaism and in Paul's letters
Paul's use of the motif of 'judgment according to deeds' corresponds terminologically, rhetorically, and theologically with its use in second temple Judaism. In order to demonstrate this thesis, the author examines the tradition- history of the motif in the Jewish Scriptures, the OT Pseudepigrapha, and the Qum- ran literature. By the beginning of the common era 'judgment according to deeds' is a widespread, fundamental theological axiom, applicable to a variety of rhetorical purposes. The motif has an important soteriological function within what is now commonly termed Jewish 'covenantal nomism' (not legalism). This judgment does not entail a one-for-one recompense of good or evil deeds, but views works wholistically (i.e., as a whole either good or bad), and thus as revealing one's 'way' of life or 'heart'. One's deeds do not earn or merit God's grace and salvation; nevertheless, one's recompense-the blessings or the curses of the covenant-will be congruent with (~according to~) this pattern of behavior, since one's works reveal what is hidden in the heart, either loyalty or disloyalty to God and his covenant. Salvation by covenant mercy and judgment according to works are complementary. In both its form
Yinger, Kent L.
Philosophy
To each according to deeds : divine judgement according to deeds in second temple Judaism and in Paul's letters. Paul's use of the motif of 'judgment according to deeds' corresponds terminologically, rhetorically, and theologically with its use in second temple Judaism. In order to demonstrate this thesis, the author examines the tradition- history of the motif in the Jewish Scriptures, the OT Pseudepigrapha, and the Qum- ran literature. By the beginning of the common era 'judgment according to deeds' is a widespread, fundamental theological axiom, applicable to a variety of rhetorical purposes. The motif has an important soteriological function within what is now commonly termed Jewish 'covenantal nomism' (not legalism). This judgment does not entail a one-for-one recompense of good or evil deeds, but views works wholistically (i.e., as a whole either good or bad), and thus as revealing one's 'way' of life or 'heart'. One's deeds do not earn or merit God's grace and salvation; nevertheless, one's recompense-the blessings or the curses of the covenant-will be congruent with (~according to~) this pattern of behavior, since one's works reveal what is hidden in the heart, either loyalty or disloyalty to God and his covenant. Salvation by covenant mercy and judgment according to works are complementary. In both its form
accord deed divine judgement accord deed second_temple judaism paul_letter paul_use motif judgment accord deed corresponds rhetorically theologically use second_temple judaism order author examines tradition history motif jewish scriptures run literature begin common era judgment accord deed widespread fundamental theological axiom applicable variety rhetorical purpose motif important soteriological function_within commonly term jewish covenantal judgment entail for good evil deed view work whole either good_bad thus reveal way_life heart earn merit god_grace salvation nevertheless the blessing curse covenant will congruent according pattern behavior since work reveal hidden heart either loyalty god covenant salvation covenant mercy judgment accord work complementary form