Decline in ancient Egypt? : a reassessment of the late New Kingdom and Third Intermediate Period
The late New Kingdom and Third Intermediate Period (1215-650 BC) have been, and continue to be, interpreted as periods of decline and dramatic change within ancient Egyptian history. This thesis challenges such views through an analysis of those interpretations and the evidence used to support them. In so doing I have evaluated if these periods do reflect a decline from previous periods and if the changes were as all-encompassing as previously suggested. In order to carry out this evaluation three key processes have been examined through detailed analysis of related datasets. These will establish the complexity of the periods, and the potential for nuance within specific datasets which is masked by the current descriptions. Reference has also been made to cross-cultural comparisons and ethno-archaeological theories as many of these processes have been identified in other societies and discussed outside Egyptology. This has led to some clarity regarding the complexity of the periods, recognising the extensive level of continuity and possible explanations for the changes visible, and thus an alternative to the 'simplistic' interpretation of decline and decay.
Mushett Cole, Edward James
CC Archaeology ; D051 Ancient History
Decline in ancient Egypt? : a reassessment of the late New Kingdom and Third Intermediate Period. The late New Kingdom and Third Intermediate Period (1215-650 BC) have been, and continue to be, interpreted as periods of decline and dramatic change within ancient Egyptian history. This thesis challenges such views through an analysis of those interpretations and the evidence used to support them. In so doing I have evaluated if these periods do reflect a decline from previous periods and if the changes were as all-encompassing as previously suggested. In order to carry out this evaluation three key processes have been examined through detailed analysis of related datasets. These will establish the complexity of the periods, and the potential for nuance within specific datasets which is masked by the current descriptions. Reference has also been made to cross-cultural comparisons and ethno-archaeological theories as many of these processes have been identified in other societies and discussed outside Egyptology. This has led to some clarity regarding the complexity of the periods, recognising the extensive level of continuity and possible explanations for the changes visible, and thus an alternative to the 'simplistic' interpretation of decline and decay.
decline ancient_egypt reassessment late new kingdom third intermediate period late new kingdom third intermediate period continue interpret period decline dramatic_change within ancient_egyptian history challenge_view analysis_interpretation evidence use_support them evaluate period reflect decline previous period change all encompassing previously_suggest order carry evaluation three_key process examine detailed_analysis relate datasets establish complexity period potential nuance within specific datasets mask current description reference also_make cross_cultural comparison ethno archaeological_theory many process identify society discuss outside egyptology lead clarity regard complexity period recognise extensive level continuity possible_explanation change visible thus alternative simplistic interpretation decline decay