Osthoff's law : a study in Greek historical phonology
The vowel shortening known as Osthoff's Law (*VRC > VRC) has been an established rule of early Greek phonology for over a century. Despite sporadic objections, it is generally accepted as a genuine historical shortening. However, developments in Indo-European and Greek linguistics have meant that Osthoff's examples are now much less certain: it is hard to prove that they ever contained a long vowel. The degree to which this affects the corpus of Osthoff shortenings is demonstrated by a detailed investigation of the forms involved. Osthoff' s Law is closely tied in with a problematic area of PIE phonological reconstruction: the original syllabification and subsequent development of *-VHRCsequences. The extent to which these two issues depend upon each other is demonstrated and discussed. It is then shown that OL has further importance for other controversial issues of PIE reconstruction. The Classical Greek forms which apparently escaped Osthoff shortening can reveal more about the details of this sound law. A particularly important case is the set of ' phonologically immune' sequences, which provide a key insight into the real nature of Osthoff's Law. The phonological issues are considered, beginning with
Simkin, Oliver Benedict
Osthoff's law : a study in Greek historical phonology. The vowel shortening known as Osthoff's Law (*VRC > VRC) has been an established rule of early Greek phonology for over a century. Despite sporadic objections, it is generally accepted as a genuine historical shortening. However, developments in Indo-European and Greek linguistics have meant that Osthoff's examples are now much less certain: it is hard to prove that they ever contained a long vowel. The degree to which this affects the corpus of Osthoff shortenings is demonstrated by a detailed investigation of the forms involved. Osthoff' s Law is closely tied in with a problematic area of PIE phonological reconstruction: the original syllabification and subsequent development of *-VHRCsequences. The extent to which these two issues depend upon each other is demonstrated and discussed. It is then shown that OL has further importance for other controversial issues of PIE reconstruction. The Classical Greek forms which apparently escaped Osthoff shortening can reveal more about the details of this sound law. A particularly important case is the set of ' phonologically immune' sequences, which provide a key insight into the real nature of Osthoff's Law. The phonological issues are considered, beginning with
law study greek historical phonology vowel shorten know law establish rule early greek phonology century despite sporadic objection generally_accept genuine historical however development indo_european greek linguistics mean example much_less certain hard prove ever contain long vowel degree affect corpus demonstrate detailed_investigation form involve law closely tie problematic_area phonological reconstruction original subsequent_development extent issue depend_upon demonstrate discuss show importance controversial issue reconstruction classical_greek form apparently escape shorten reveal detail sound law particularly_important case set phonologically immune sequence provide_key insight real nature law phonological issue_consider begin